Web Analytics Made Easy -
StatCounter
Tsallake zuwa content

MediaLight da Lumadoodle: Babban Bambanci

Aunar MediaLight:

Yanzu na sami gidan yanar gizon ku. Ina zuwa daga Lumadoodle da na lalata lokacin da na koma sabon gida. Shin akwai dalilin da yasa fitilunku suka fi tsada? Kamar zaku iya nuna mani ainihin bayanai?

Amrit S.

Barka dai Amrit.

Godiya ga sakonka kuma don Allah a gafarta jinkirin amsa. Mun sami wannan tambayar da yawa. Yawancin lokaci nakan amsa da tambaya ta tawa:

Shin kuna adana kuɗi idan kun sayi samfurin da baya yin abin da yakamata yayi?

Muna yin fitilun da ba su da tsada mai tsada wanda yayi daidai da na Lumadoodle, yayin bayar da daidaito na ƙwararru, garanti mai tsayi da ƙarin zaɓuɓɓukan haɗi. 

Don haka, idan kuna neman yin kwatancen da ya dace, zan kwatanta Lumadoodle da sabon sabo LX1 Hasken Wutar Lantarki daga wannan ƙungiyar MediaLight.

Akwai abubuwa da yawa da za a iya samar da cikakken haske na son zuciya fiye da ɗaukar ƙaramin CRI (75 Ra kawai) na zango na LED, "cire bututun filastik da sanya kwali a baya," kamar yadda Lumadoodle ke so ku yi imani.

Idan ba kwa son yin mummunan tasiri ga hoton TV, to akwai ƙa'idodi don CRI (Fitar da Launin Launin Launi), chromaticity da rarraba wutar lantarki ta yanayi mai haske wanda ya kamata a bi. 

Kamfaninmu ya kwashe shekaru bakwai yana inganta ingantattun abubuwa da fasalolin samfuranmu yayin da nasu bai inganta ba kwata-kwata, kuma mun san cewa har yanzu akwai sauran ci gaba, wanda shine dalilin da ya sa muke aiki koyaushe kan gaba. Wannan shine dalilin da yasa ƙwararrun bidiyo ke amfani da samfuran MediaLight a kusan kowane ɗakin karatu da kayan aikin samar da post. 

Ya tafi ba tare da faɗi ba, amma ba mu da alaƙa da Lumadoodle, Govee, Antec, Zabiki ko wani dabam .. Koyaya, abin da ke biyo baya yana kauce wa ra'ayi kuma yana mai da hankali kan bayanan yanayin yanayin hoto da ƙirar jiki. 

Amma, koma ga tambayarku. Ina so in sami ikon aika cikakkiyar amsa tare da ainihin bayanai, don haka kawai na ba da umarnin sabon rukunin Lumadoodle kuma na auna shi ƙarƙashin Sekonic C7000.

Da farko, bari mu cire tube daga kayan aikin su kuma kalli Lumadoodle kusa da MediaLight. Abu na farko da zaku lura shine MediaLight yana da ƙarin ledoji. Tsiri 5m Lumadoodle yana da LEDs 90. MediaLight mai tsayi iri ɗaya yana da LEDs 150. Akwai ƙarin LEDs akan 66.66% akan MediaLight da mita. 

Kwatanta Lumadoodle da MediaLight 
LED Yawa

 

Chips din a cikin MediaLight zai kashe fiye da kashi 66% bisa yawan yawaitar LED kawai ko da kuwa an samu ƙasa da ƙasa, mafi girman daidaiton kwakwalwan SMD ba su da tsada don ƙera su. Gaskiyar ita ce, suna da tsada a kalla 20 sau fiye da kowane LED. 

Kwatanta nuna bambanci haske Ingancin LED

Da farko, bari dai kawai in ce wannan ba kwatankwacin apples-to-apples bane.

MediaLight an tsara ta ne ta hanyar kwararrun masana kimiyya Lumadoodle ba. MediaLight ya ƙunshi keɓaɓɓun launukan launi na Mk2 da Lumadoodle ba. Wannan ba shine ya bugi mutanen da ke aiki a can ba, tunda su mutane ne masu kirki, kawai ba sa la'akari da ƙimar hoto yayin gina samfuran su kuma suna da gaskiya game da shi. Mun fi son wannan ga kamfanonin da suma ke sayar da leda masu ƙarancin ƙarfi amma suna da'awar cewa suna da gaskiya. 

Na gwada Lumadoodle fewan shekarun da suka gabata kuma na zaci, kamar yadda yake tare da fasaha mai yawa, cewa da an sami ci gaba da haɓaka tun daga lokacin. A zahiri, CRI (alamar fassarar launi) har yanzu yana ƙasa sosai duk da cewa fasahar LED ta ci gaba sosai a cikin shekaru 5 da suka gabata.

Lumadsle Fitar da Launin Launi (CRI) = 76.3 Ra (rashi)
Fihirisar Bayar da Launi na MediaLight (CRI) ≥ 98 Ra 

Ga bambanci, na farko (gwajin bayan-beta) MediaLight da aka siyar a 2015 ya nuna CRI na 91 (yanzu 98-99 Ra). Amma, har ma da MediaLight na 2015 yana da CRI mafi girma fiye da Lumadoodle na yau.

Sabon tsiri ya auna wanda ya fi na baya baya, wanda har yanzu zaka iya ganin ma'aunina a nan daga 2017, amma har yanzu gaskiya kusa da CCT da aka tallata na 6000K (akan tsarin daidaitaccen 6500K). 

Me nake nufi gaskiya rufe?

Duniya ta nuna haske ta son zuciya ita ce Wild West. Akwai matakan masana'antu masu tsauri, amma kaɗan ne kawai ke bin su.

Mun ƙaddamar da samfuranmu don takaddun shaida mai zaman kanta ta ISF, yayin da yawancin kamfanoni ke buga "6500K" kawai a kan kunshin, ko "fararen fari", ko "fari na gaskiya." Sau ɗaya na sayi ɗaya don gwadawa wanda aka ce "farin farin" a kan fakitin. 😁

Biyu daga cikin mafi munin masu laifi, kodayake sune Vansky da Antec. Sun kasance mummunan da gaske cewa sun cutar da amfani da su. Idan kun taɓa tafiya a cikin bene ko filin ajiye motoci tare da kwalliya, fitilu masu haske, kun san abin da nake nufi. 

Hasken Vansky Bias sunyi ikirarin zafin jiki mai launi na 6500K akan gidan yanar gizon su amma auna kusan 20,000K

Antec Bias Haske ya ce cewa "an daidaita hasken fitilunsu zuwa 6500K" a shafin yanar gizon su amma su awo a 54,000K.  Ba za su sanya shi ba, sun kasance mummunan. 

Undididdigar wannan gabatarwar, Zabiki da kuma Halo Bias Haske Sun kasance masu matukar damuwa da kansu, amma, sa'a, sun riga sun fita kasuwanci, don haka ba lallai ne in sake nazarin su ba.

Don haka, a takaice amsar ita ce, an kashe kudi sosai wajen gina MediaLight saboda kasancewar akwai karin LEDs, wadanda su kansu suna da inganci - an gina su ne don takamaiman "ka'idojin kwatance," tare da gungun sauran abubuwan da kuke buƙatar yin LED a cikakken aikin son zuciya haske:

  • CRI na ≥98 maimakon 76 (hasken wuta ya zama cikakken mafi ƙarancin 90)
  • Tolearfafa haƙurin binning (a cikin 50K na 6500K)
  • Tsarin tsarkakakken jan karfe PCB
  • Yawancin kari wanda zaku buƙaci siya daban tare da sauran fitilu (Ie dimple da kuma M, adaftan, kunnawa / kashe kunnawa, igiyar tsawo, shirye-shiryen bidiyo da ake bi da waya). 
  • Shin na ambaci ƙarin LEDs 66.66% a kowane tsiri?

I alkawari cewa zan shiga cikin danyen bayanan hoto nan bada jimawa ba. Amma kafin na yi, akwai, wani ɓangare mai rikitarwa na alamar Lumadoodle wanda ke haifar da rikicewa, kuma wanda ke haifar da imel da yawa da hira ta yanar gizo zuwa gare ni. 

Ban gwada Lumadoodle Pro ba domin idan suna farin cikin buga wata magana wacce ta fi farin haskensu haske, wannan ya ishe ni. Koyaya, idan abu ɗaya kawai kuka koya daga wannan imel ɗin: "hasken canza launin son zuciya da ƙarancin launi ba sa gauraya.

Dukkanin tube na MediaLight ana kwaikwayon D65 fari. Ba sa canza launuka. 

Saboda haka, kwatancenmu yana tsakanin MediaLight Mk2 da farin Lumadoodle.

Anan ga ɗanyen bayanai a cikin tsarin .csv don aunawa daga duka hasken haske ɗauka tare da Sekonic C7000 na katin 18% mai ruwan toka a cikin ɗakin da aka zana da zanen Munsell N8. (Wataƙila kun ga yanayin haɗawarmu a wasu shafuka. Muna amfani da hakan don gwada kowane LEDs, kwararan fitila da kawunan fitila, ba tarin taru ba). 

MediaLight Mk2 (.csv)
Lumadoodle (.csv)

An auna ma'aunan da ke sama tare da tsayin 1m na kewayen LED. 

Kwatanta fasalin MediaLight da Lumadoodle

  • MediaLight ya haɗa da dimmer. Lumadoodle ba ya haɗa da dimmer don samfurinsu na fari (son zuciya ya zama ya zama D65 fari, don haka wannan muke kwatantawa), amma zaka iya siyan ɗaya kimanin $ 12
  • MediaLight ya haɗa da sauya kunna / kashewa. Lumadoodle ba. Idan tashar USB akan TV dinka bata kashe tare da TV ba, an umurce ka da cire shi. 
  • MediaLight's dimmer da aikin nesa yana aiki tare da Harmony remote ko IR na nesa, Lumadoodle bai haɗa da mai ƙwanƙwasa ba kuma rukunin da ake samu don siyarwa bai dace da daidaito da IR na nesa na duniya ba. 
  • MediaLight yana amfani da tsarkakakken jan ƙarfe PCB (alloy-nutsewa) don ƙwarewar haɓaka da ƙarfin ɗimama zafi, Lumadoodle baya yi.
  • MediaLight ya haɗa da adaftan (Arewacin Amurka kawai), Lumadoodle ba. 
  • MediaLight ya hada da Garanti na Shekara 5, kuma Garantin Lumadoodle shekara 1 ce.
  • MediaLight ba ya canza launuka kuma Lumadoodle yana yin samfurin tare da launuka daban-daban. Idan kuna son canza launuka, Lumadoodle shine zaɓi mafi kyau. Koyaya, fitilun canza launi suna tasiri tasirin hoton akan allon don kallo mai mahimmanci launi. A sakamakon haka, MediaLight ba ya ba su. 
  • MediaLight an tabbatar dashi don daidaito ta Gidauniyar Kimiyyar Hoto kuma an tsara shi don wucewa SMPTE mizanai don hasken kewaya don yanayin mahimmin yanayin bidiyo. Lumadoodle ya kusa kusa zuwa ga makasudin da aka bayyana na 6000K da 76 Ra, amma waɗannan ba matakan mizani bane.

Halin Hasken wuta

    • MediaLight LEDs an kwaikwayi D65 (6500K tare da ofuv na .003 - the Δuv na sake sake hasken rana, a layi daya da CIE mai haskakawa D65) tare da alamar fassarar launi mai tsayi (CRI) na ≥ 98 Ra. Theididdigar yanayin chromaticity suna kusa kusa da x = 0.3127, y = daidaitaccen 0.329.

    • Lumadoodle na tallata tallan ƙarancin zafin jiki na 6000K (akan wasu shafuka) kuma ƙididdigar mu suna tabbatar da hakan. Sun fi 6500K zafi (kusan 5600K don wannan samfurin). Alamar ma'anar launi ta Lumadoodle ta 76 tana ƙasa da SMPTE-bada shawara mafi ƙarancin darajar 90 Ra.
Da ma'anar magana, fitilun CRI mafi girma sun fi daidaito fiye da ƙananan fitilun CRI, kuma 76 tana ƙasa da ƙofar don ingantaccen hoto.  
    • MediaLight yana da darajar R9 (ja mai zurfi) of 97. Lumadoodle yana da ƙimar R9 mara kyau. Wannan yana nufin cewa Lumadoodle ba shi da zurfin ja a yanayinsa, aƙalla ba shi da alaƙa da sauran launuka a cikin bakan.
      • Haske mai haske (R9) mai mahimmanci yana da mahimmanci ga sautin fata daidai da gudanawar jini da ke ƙarƙashin fata. (Wannan yana da mahimmanci koda tare da nuni mai watsawa, kodayake tasirin ya juya). Hakanan yana bayanin dalilin da yasa fitilun ke son samun kore / shuɗi idan aka kwatanta da manyan hasken CRI. Hasken ya ƙunshi kololuwa shuɗi da rawaya.

      Rarraba pectarfin Spectral da CRI na MediaLight Mk2

      Rarraba pectarfin Spectral da CRI na Lumadoodle

      Zai iya zama ƙalubale don ganin banbanci tsakanin rarraba hasken wutar lantarki na samfuran haske guda biyu, saboda haka zamu rufa jadawalin. An rarraba rarraba wutar lantarki don Lumadoodle a gaban MediaLight Mk2. Lumadoodle ya bayyana kamar fari mai haske tare da iyakar baki kuma MediaLight Mk2 ya bayyana a launi. 

      Mun ga cewa Lumadoodle ya kirkiri fari ta hanyar hada phosphors mai launin rawaya (phosphors tare da tsayin nisan 580 nm) tare da shuɗar shuɗi. Babu ja ko koren ƙira a cikin samfurin Lumadoodle (zaka iya yin ƙananan farin CRI ta haɗu da launuka biyu na haske - rawaya da shuɗi).  

      Kuna iya ganin raƙuman kore da ja daban na MediaLight Mk2 kuma launuka waɗanda suka yi kyau sosai akan jadawalin suna wakiltar launuka da suka ɓace daga Lumadoodle bakan. Farin "tsaunin dutse" yana wakiltar matakin ƙwanƙolin ƙarfin kuzarin phosphors a cikin Lumadoodle.  

      MediaLight ba ya ƙunsar ƙwanƙolin rawaya yayin haɗuwa da faffadan-kunkuntun band ja da koren phosphors ana haɗe su da shuɗar shuɗi don ba MediaLight Mk2 SPD siffar da ta fi kusa da D65, ko "kwaikwayon D65."

        karshe

        Duk da yake wannan kwatancen yana zuwa ne daga abokin fafatawarsu, ba kamar wasu samfuran da ke kasuwa ba, Lumadoodle ba ya da'awar an tsara shi don daidaito, kuma farashin ya yi ƙasa da farashin MediaLight, kodayake ba lallai ba ne ƙasa da irin wannan kayan kayan aikin LED. Ya bambanta wannan da kamfanonin da suka yi alkawarin fiye da yadda suke bayarwa. Suna da alamar CRI na 76 kuma wannan shine abin da kuka samu.

        Kudin tabbas tabbas lamari ne kuma koda mafi kyawun fitilun son zuciya ba zai adana mummunan TV tare da saitunan da ba daidai ba.

        Mun fi so kada mu sayar wa mutanen da ba sa buƙata ko suke son daidaito. Akwai mutane da yawa da ke amfani da TV kai tsaye daga akwatin fiye da mutanen da ke daidaita abubuwan da suke nunawa. 

        Muna fatan, duk da haka, mun nuna dalilin da yasa samfuranmu suka fi tsada don ƙera don ku yanke shawarar wane samfurin ya dace da ku.

        A nan ne waɗanda suka kafa Lumadoodle suna magana game da samfuran hasken wutan lantarki na son zuciya da kuma yadda suke da hankali daban. Wannan ba sabon abu bane. Yawancin LEDs da aka siyar azaman fitilun son zuciya sune kayayyaki masu haske na LED waɗanda aka tsara don dalilai da yawa, kamar fitilun alfarwa.

        Haskenmu zai haifar da fitilun alfarwa, amma fitilu ne na son zuciya. Koyaya, akwai yanayi inda daidaituwa ba ta da mahimmanci, kuma biyan kuɗi don daidaito bai cancanci ƙarin kuɗin ba. Kada ku taɓa siyan wani abu wanda yakai kuɗi fiye da yadda kuke son biya don sifofin da baku buƙata. 

        Idan kun daidaita TV ɗinka, fitilun da basu dace ba ku daidaita shi ta mahangar masu kallo. Bambance-bambancen fahimta tsakanin yanayin chromaticity da fassarar launi na MediaLight da Lumadoodle shine, a mafi yawan lokuta, yafi matuka fiye da tweaks ɗin da zaku gabatar a bayyane, kuma tunda fitilu suna ba da nuni na fari fari, ana ganin canjin yanayi a yanayin zafi kuma tint zai dace da wannan bambanci. 

        Idan hasken yanayi a yanayin kallo yayi dumi sosai kuma yana da Δuv wanda yayi tsayi da yawa, zai yi haske da dumi fiye da d65 ɗin da aka kwaikwaya. Sakamakon haka, TV zata fi D65 kyau da sanyi fiye da DXNUMX, koda kuwa an sanya shi aiki. 

        Kuma ko da ba tare da bambancin daidaito ba, akwai wasu abubuwan da kuke son ƙarawa zuwa Lumadoodle don sanya shi kwatancen apples-to-apples dangane da farashi, Waɗannan abubuwa sun haɗa da naúrar nesa, mai rage haske (hasken wuta saita zuwa 10% na iyakar haske na nuni, saboda haka kuna buƙatar dimmer) adaftan AC, igiyar haɓaka, ƙimar LED mafi girma da kuma lokacin garanti mai tsayi. Dingara kayan haɗi yana rufe rarar farashin da yawa. 

        Mabudin ciniki shine ɗayan tsada bisa daidaito. Idan baku sami daidaito da kuke buƙata ba, mai yiwuwa kuna biyan kuɗi da yawa, duk da ƙaramin farashi. Kuma, idan baku buƙatar daidaito, kuna iya zama mafi alh offri tare da samfur mai arha, maimakon ɗayan samfuran da aka duba akan wannan shafin.

        Wannan kwatancen ban sha'awa ne. Wadanne fitilu kake son gani a gaba?